Recent Draft History – Evaluating the first 3 rounds of the last 5 Drafts for each team. I’ve left out 2016, as it’s way too early to tell on 95% of the picks. Instead, this will be examining drafts from 2011 to 2015.
2011 NHL Entry Draft
Round 1 – Ryan Murphy (D) 12th overall – Murphy is by no-means a bust, but he’s not quite what everyone thought he’d be. He’s quickly becoming expendably for the Hurricanes, and while he’s played 151 games, he’s likely not going to be around for much longer in the NHL. That’s tough to swallow for Carolina, being a 12th overall pick only 6 years ago.
Round 2 – Victor Rask (C) 42nd overall – Rask has developed into a top-line player for Carolina, and had another campaign where he approached 50 points. I think he’s better off on the second line, but I would consider this a much better pick than Murphy.
Round 3 – Keegan Lowe (D) 73rd overall – Lowe was traded to Montreal for a prospect of the same level, and he will likely not play in the NHL. He hasn’t developed as they would have hoped, and the Canes would want this pick back, with plenty of players taken after him who have a brighter future.
2012 NHL Entry Draft
Round 1 – Pick was traded with Brandon Sutter and Brian Dumolin to Pittsburgh for Jordan Staal. I don’t like the trade much, as that’s a lot to give up for what I believe is at best a 2nd line centre. Carolina was not in any position to make a push for the Cup, and would have been better off keeping what was the 8th overall pick, especially with the likes of Filip Forsberg, Jacob Trouba, Tomas Hertl and many others still available.
Round 2 – Phil Di Giuseppe (LW) 38th overall – Giuseppe had 7 points in 36 NHL games, and likely won’t grow those production numbers any higher. Disappointing pick early in round 2, as Carolina needs all the help they can get offensively.
Round 2 – Brock McGinn (LW) 47th overall – Received this pick from San Jose for Ian White. Played in 57 NHL games this year, scoring only 16 points, which is disappointing. Carolina is weak up front, and will likely want to upgrade over McGinn if possible. Right now, he’ll need to have a good camp to stick with the team long-term.
Round 3 – Daniel Altshuller (G) 69th overall – Had great numbers this year in the ECHL, and average in the AHL. He’s a big goalie, but will need to have a better year next season if he’s ever hoping to be looked at as a potential NHL goaltender.
Note: Jaccob Slavin drafted 4th round. He has played in 145 games and is in the top-4 on Carolina currently, great young defender.
2013 NHL Entry Draft
Round 1 – Elias Lindholm (C) 5th overall – Lindholm had 45 points in 72 NHL games, his 4th year in the league. He made the jump quickly, and has been growing his game each season. Carolina would definitely want to re-do this pick however, with Sean Monahan going after him in the draft. Lindholm is a good young player, but Monahan plays the game better at both ends of the rink.
Round 2 – Pick was traded to the Sabres for Andrej Sekera. The pick hasn’t turned into a great player (JT Compher), while Sekera played the better parts of 2 seasons in Carolina, before being flipped to LA for a 1st round pick in 2016. Great trade for Carolina here, as they benefited in two separate ways.
Round 3 – Brett Pesce (D) 66th overall – Played in all 82 games this year, and appears to be part of the blueline permanently in Carolina. He had a great year, despite playing on a weak Carolina team. Pesce can drive play well from the backend, and is dependable in his own end. Great find in round 3 by the Canes.
2014 NHL Entry Draft
Round 1 – Haydn Fleury (D) 7th overall – One of the few players from the first round of this draft who’s yet to play an NHL game, Fleury has become a big disappointment for Carolina. Many better options were available, including William Nylander, Dylan Larkin, David Pastrnak, etc etc.
Round 2 – Alex Nedeljkovic (G) 37th overall – Made his NHL debut this year as an injury call-up, but spent most of the year in the ECHL/AHL. He had solid numbers in the ECHL, but struggled in the AHL. He’s likely a few years away from a legitimate shot, but is trending in the right direction.
Round 3 – Warren Foegele (C) 67th overall – Foegele had a great year in junior, and will start next year in the AHL. He’s not likely on the NHL radar anytime soon, but has been a great offensive player in his junior career, something which Carolina is in need of. Looks like a good pick in the 3rd round, as he has grown well since being drafted.
2015 NHL Entry Draft
Round 1 – Noah Hanifin (D) 5th overall – Hanifin has developed into a top-pairing D-man, which the Canes had hoped for. I don’t believe they would change this pick, as he fits their organizational need perfectly currently, and at that time.
Round 2 – Sebastian Aho (LW) 35th overall – Aho has turned into a steal at this pick, as he just turned in an impressive rookie campaign with 49 points in 82 games. If it were not for super rookies Auston Matthews and Patrick Laine, he’d be front and centre for rookie of the year. Great steal in round 2.
Round 3 – Pick was traded to Vancouver with a 7th round pick for Eddie Lack. Lack hasn’t been the starter they hoped for, and struggled mightily this season, but they didn’t give up a lot to get him, and needed a better backup than what they had at the time.
Carolina has missed on a few key picks, which could have shaped their organization a lot differently. They need offense and goaltending, and should be able to move some of their defense prospects/players to get some, because they haven’t been as successful as they’d hoped in drafting some.